Tanmay Mehta[*]

Keywords:   Criminal law -Extraterritoriality – IGA – International Space Station – Outer Space Treaty 

Even though space law is itself an evolving field, one field that may present (when applied in space) myriad complex challenges due to the unique nature of its applicability is criminal law. Till now, the jurisprudence of space law has not been confronted with a matter which has tested the applicability and contours of criminal law in space. It is also interesting to note that no one has yet been formally charged, let alone convicted, for the commission of a crime in space. However, as space becomes increasingly accessible and more open to the private sector, we are bound to see instances of unlawful activities in space too. For example, in 2019, a NASA astronaut allegedly hacked the bank account of her estranged spouse while she was aboard the International Space Station. The claims against the astronaut, however, were later found to be false. States at the individual level have also been making an effort to cover this uncovered field. An example of this is Canada’s Budget Bill of 2022 which contained provisions to crack down on space crimes. The Bill, inter alia, extended the applicability of criminal law to outer space by providing that “a Canadian crew member who, during a space flight, commits an act or omission outside Canada that, if committed in Canada, would constitute an indictable offence is deemed to have committed that act or omission in Canada, if that act or omission is committed(a) on, or in relation to, a flight element of the Lunar Gateway;(b) on any means of transportation to or from the Lunar Gateway; or(c) on the surface of the Moon.” With this brief background and general overview, this write-up explores the hitherto not much-explored area concerning the applicability of criminal law in space in the following sections. 

Application of Criminal Law and Jurisdictional Ambiguity in Space

One of the major issues relating to the applicability and functioning of criminal law in space is the nature of the law itself. Criminal law, by its very nature in the traditional setting, is territorial and is applicable only within the national frontiers of a State. Thus, determining the applicable law and jurisdiction in cases concerning a field which has no boundaries and is not subject to the territorial rights of States may prove to be problematic and require consideration of a variety of issues. The extraterritorial application of criminal law and the exercise of criminal jurisdiction in space are in search of a proper connecting factor so that a relevant State law and jurisdiction can be applied. Scholars are divided on using either nationality of the offender or victim or registration of space objects as the connecting factor to apply criminal law and exercise jurisdiction. The nationality-based approach proposes that, regardless of where the space object is registered, criminal law should be enforced depending on the nationality of the individuals participating in the illegal act. This strategy adheres to the established idea that a nation’s laws are applicable to all of its residents, wherever they may be. In other words, this approach adheres to one of the most basic principles of classical international law—that international law would not interfere with the relationship between a sovereign state and its nationals. However, in cases involving multi-national space missions, this approach may present difficulties in determining jurisdictional issues. Moreover, there is also a divide between the active personality and passive personality principles for applying nationality as a connecting factor since the former goes by the nationality of the offender and the latter advocates for the nationality of the victim.

The registration-based approach, on the other hand, suggests that criminal law be implemented based on the registration of the space object participating in the illegal action. If this approach were to be followed, the criminal act would be under the jurisdiction of the country of registration of the space object on which the crime is committed. In disputes involving space objects owned by commercial corporations or multinational organisations, proponents of this approach argue that it offers clearer rules and is the least controversial principle for the determination of applicable law and jurisdiction. In other words, this approach may be better suited for the present purposes because space missions frequently involve astronauts and employees from multiple countries. However, there may be jurisdictional gaps in situations where criminal behaviour is directly connected to a specific person or group of people rather than the space object itself. Further, this approach might not fully address circumstances in which criminal activities are carried out by parties outside the registered space object, such as cyber-attacks on spacecraft or distant operations impacting space missions. Traditional ideas of territorial jurisdiction may not be adequate in these situations to prosecute the offenders. The lack of legal precedents further exacerbates the jurisdictional ambiguity surrounding unlawful conduct in space. In addition to this, we must not forget that the field of space law is still relatively new and continually developing, and due to the lack of established legal frameworks, decision-making becomes more difficult.

Existing Legal Framework

In the interim, till a comprehensive framework is developed for the purpose of regulating criminal activities in space, we may make use of the existing frameworks to decide issues relating to applicable law and jurisdiction. For this purpose, we may reconcile and interpret the Intergovernmental Agreement on the International Space Station (hereinafter “IGA”) and specific provisions of the Outer Space Treaty in a manner that would allow us to determine the questions concerning criminal activities in space. Unfortunately, neither IGA nor Outer Space Treaty addresses the question of applicable law separately rather, they confine themselves to jurisdictional issues. 

IGA provides detailed rules concerning jurisdictional issues in relation to criminal misconduct in space. In cases involving individuals from the same nation, Article 22(1) of the IGA specifically states that parties to the said agreement may “exercise criminal jurisdiction over personnel in or on any flight element who are their respective nationals.” In cases where the misconduct “….(a) affects the life or safety of a national of another Partner State or (b) occurs in or on or causes damage to the flight element of another Partner State”, IGA provides for a consultative process under Article 22(2). It provides that the affected Partner State may request a consultation with the Partner State to whom the alleged perpetrator belongs concerning their respective “prosecutorial interests.” It further provides that the affected Partner State may exercise criminal jurisdiction against the alleged perpetrator if the Partner State whose national is the alleged perpetrator fails to either “(1) concur in such exercise of criminal jurisdiction, or (2) provide assurances that it will submit the case to its competent authorities for the purpose of prosecution.” Article 22(4) further mandates that each Partner State has to cooperate and assist other Partner States in relation to misconduct in orbit. 

In addition to the IGA, Outer Space Treaty also provides under Article VIII that the jurisdiction and control over space objects and personnel thereof shall lie with the nation on whose registry that object is registered. This combines personal jurisdiction with quasi-territorial jurisdiction on the basis of registration as the connecting factor. Interestingly, it does not consider nationality even in conferring personal jurisdiction over the personnel of space objects.

The above discussion on IGA and the Outer Space Treaty shows how a mixed approach needs to be followed concerning issues relating to the scope and contours of criminal law in space. It requires us to follow the nationality principle in conjunction with the principle relating to the registration of objects. However, this may not essentially work in the long run as there is every possibility of conflict between nationality and registration as connecting factors in future space crimes. The framework discussed above, with reconciling connecting factors, may be used as an inspiration to develop more comprehensive rules and guidelines governing criminal misconduct in space. This is not an easy task, given the unwillingness of States to involve themselves in the consultative processes to come to an agreement on their respective prosecutorial interests. 

Conclusion

As space activities continue to advance, the need for a more robust and comprehensive legal framework becomes increasingly evident. Establishing a dedicated body of space criminal law, informed by international cooperation and consensus, is crucial for addressing current ambiguity in the determination of applicable law and jurisdiction. Additionally, international collaboration among space-faring nations is essential to create a cohesive legal framework that ensures accountability and upholds justice in the ever-expanding frontier of outer space. Addressing this issue requires a collective effort from the international community to develop a comprehensive and coherent legal framework that caters specifically to the challenges of space crimes. Only through cooperation, innovation, and dedication we can create a system that ensures that justice prevails in the uncharted and rapidly evolving frontier of outer space.


[*]The author is a Junior Associate at the Chamber of Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General of India. The author would like to thank Prof (Dr) Sandeepa Bhat for his valuable feedback and suggestions. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *