P. Paul Fitzgerald*

Keywords:  Bermuda Agreement – Bermuda II – Open skies – Privity of contract – Transit Agreement

Introduction

Around the world, most international airline passengers fly with an airline based in the country of the origin or destination of their flight. Indeed, this is pretty much the practice everywhere, except on routes between the United States and India. More often than not, passengers travelling between the United States and India fly with airlines based in Qatar and the United Arab Emirates[1] who offer almost unbeatable one-stop service between 12 cities in India and 12 cities in the United States.

From a short-term consumer view, the services of the Emirati and Qatari airlines are attractive; you fly from your home town in India, to a fabulous airport in the Middle East with exciting Duty-Free Shopping, and you need no visa to transfer to the flight to your destination in the United States. From a long-term view, one might ask whether a Delhi-Doha-Houston service, impedes the launch by Indian or American carriers of non-stop flights between Delhi and America’s fourth largest city. This is not a theoretical question; there are non-stop flights from Houston to Sydney and Tokyo but not to Delhi.

This article will explore the Gap between United States-Japan and United States-India air services as an example, and consider ways to fix this gap.

BASA Concepts

A Bilateral Air Service Agreement (BASA) is a treaty that governs the commercial aviation relationship between its two signatory States.  Through the BASA, the two signatory States negotiate the terms and conditions of the routes that their airlines will fly along, including the frequency of flights, aircraft size, cities to be served and other issues such as repatriation of profits, the ability to contract independent aircraft handlers, and security and marketing concerns.

A)   Privity of Contract

An essential element of a BASA is privity of contract in that the market created by the BASA is to be the exclusive purview of the airlines designated by the BASA’s signatory States. For example, within two years of the signing of the Chicago Convention, the United States and the United Kingdom had negotiated the 1946 Bermuda Agreement which had, as its raison d’être, the regulation of traffic between those two States. Yet, the importance of the even distribution of traffic between the airlines designated by the two States cannot be exaggerated. When the United Kingdom learned that United States airlines were earning three times as much as British airlines from the routes between the United Kingdom and the United States, the United Kingdom renounced the Bermuda Agreement.[2]

The negotiations of Bermuda II, were focused on two things; the United Kingdom – United States commercial aviation market needed to be divided evenly between the airlines designated by the United Kingdom or the United States, and the dominant carriers operating on routes between the two States should be American and British. This renegotiation became possible due to the operation of privity of contracts.

The principle that the airlines designated by the signatory States to a BASA, should be the dominant carrier on routes between the two BASA partners is central to the success of the BASA. Moreover, if they are not the dominant carriers, as has been seen in the United Kingdom – United States example above, the airlines will complain and may cause the BASA to be renegotiated or simply renounced. Indeed, if this principle is not observed, the BASA may not be necessary.

B)   Open Skies

An Open Skies BASA is just like any other BASA except that the basic terms and conditions are set by market principles rather than by government officials. Thus, in the 2007 United States– European Union ASA, the airlines are the ones deciding what cities they will serve, how often, with what size of plane and via which routing.

The market discipline ensures proper decision making. No European or American airline would offer non-stop wide-body service between Bucharest and Omaha, simply because there is no market for non-stop flights between these two cities.[3] Airlines will fly the obvious trunk routes, such as between New York and London, but others will use the power of their hubs to operate more marginal routes.

At the current time, none of the airlines based in North America or Europe is government-backed and so market principles prevail in all of these BASAs, competition is fair and these BASAs are working well.

United States-Japan and United States-India BASA: Comparing Air Services

Both India and Japan have Open Skies agreements with the United States. In December 2023, six airlines from Japan or the United States offered 287 weekly non-stop flights on 24 routes between Japan and the United States.[4] In the same month, three airlines from India or the United States offered 58 weekly non-stop flights on nine routes between India and the United States.[5]

If one considers that India has roughly ten times Japan’s population and that both Japan and India are amongst the top six sources of foreign tourist to the United States, one might expect at least equal airline services from both India and Japan to the United States.

Assuming that Japan- United States and India- United States markets are roughly comparable, there is a gap of over 200 flights a week between the former and the latter.  Of note, Qatar Airways offers over 84 flights a week between Doha and 12 cities in the United States and each of those connect in both directions with flights between Doha and 12 cities in India.

Understanding Doha as a Transit Point

In order to understand Qatar Airways’ power as an interloper in the United States-India BASA, it is helpful to be aware of the air services that would normally be expected of similarly populated countries and Qatar Airways’ view of its Doha hub.

What kind of air service would Doha normally have?

Even if you include the various expatriate workers, Qatar’s population is just 2.97 million, comparable to that of Jamaica.  Thus, if Kingston, Jamaica does not warrant a daily flight to London, how can Doha merit non-stop flights to 12 cities in the United States?  Moreover, if Doha is such a popular destination for Americans, why is it that no airline, based in the America, and which is not allied in some form with Qatar Airways, serves Doha?

Doha is not a destination; it is a transit point according to Qatar Airways’ CEO

Qatar Airways’ explicit focus on aggressive 6th Freedom practice and being an interloper in various BASA was unwittingly revealed in 2010 by the airline’s then-Chief Executive Office, Akbar Al Baker, when he launched the airline’s non-stop route to Sao Paulo. He stated;

“With a large Lebanese and Japanese community living in Brazil, Argentina and neighbouring South American countries, the route is a perfect match for our business model, which carries passengers from East to West and vice versa via our Doha hub.”

Qatar Airways’ use of aggressive 6th Freedom practices, and its status as a major interloper into various BASAs has produced dramatic negative consequences in virtually every market that Qatar Airways serves. In Europe, the United States and Asia, the dominant carriers based in the State partners of the applicable BASA have complained that non-stop routes between the BASA partners have been made less commercially viable due to the aggressive 6th Freedom operations of interloper carriers such as Qatar Airways.[6]

Remedies

Sadly, there are very few practical remedies to deal with the interloper problem.  Given that the interlopers are based in States that are not Parties to the United States-India BASA, there is almost nothing that can be done.  There are, however, two options that are very serious and may have significant implications. They are for India to withdraw from the International Air Services Transit Agreement (Transit Agreement) and for India to consult with Qatar or cancel its BASA with Qatar. For the purpose of this analysis, Qatar has been chosen as it has a tiny population and little tourism potential and Qatar Airways is therefore even more dependent on aggressive 6th Freedom operations than Emirates or Etihad.[7] These same factors give Qatar Airways enhanced status as an interloper in dozens of BASAs.

A)   Withdraw from the Transit Agreement

India is a Party to the Transit Agreement by which it grants airlines of other counties to overfly its territory and make stops for non-traffic purposes.  By withdrawing from the Transit Agreement, India would be firing a diplomatic shot across the bow, without immediately affecting any traffic rights of any airline. It must be noted that withdrawing from the Transit Agreement requires giving a year’s notice to the international community under Article III.

Once a State has withdrawn from the Transit Agreement, in order to overfly that State or to make landing there for non-traffic purposes another State must have a BASA with that State. Canada withdrew from the Transit Agreement in 1988 and recently used the fact that it is no longer a party to the Transit Agreement to force the United Arab Emirates to drop its feud with Canada over Canada’s refusal to grant them more liberal traffic rights.

The United Arab Emirates finally realized that as a non-Party to the Transit Agreement, if Canada were to withdraw from the Canada- United Arab Emirates BASA, Canada would be in a position to deny overflight of its territory to flights of Emirates and Etihad to most cities in the United States.

India’s territory is sufficiently expansive that even the threat of withdrawing from the Transit Agreement would get significant attention. This reality would strengthen India’ bargaining position when negotiating BASA as a denial of overflight could result in the cancellation of many flights by carriers based in States who had not been able to negotiate a BASA acceptable to India.

B)   Re-negotiate or cancel its BASA with Qatar

If India withdraws from the Transit Agreement it will be in a much stronger position to negotiate with Qatar. Other than the back-and-forth travel of heavily exploited Indian guest-workers in Qatar, there is very little bilateral tourism traffic between Qatar and India. For travel minded Indians, Qatar has relatively few attractions compared to Dubai, Europe or other parts of India. As an attraction of Qatari tourists, the only downside is that number of Qataris with the disposable income to travel as tourists to India is roughly a million.[8]

If India did not have a BASA with Qatar, travel between India and Qatar could be routed through Dubai or Bahrain; thus, India does not need a BASA with Qatar! It is Qatar that wants the BASA! As explained above, without access to India, Qatar Airways flights to the United States are no longer as viable. India can dramatically affect the fortunes of Qatar Airways.

Secure in this knowledge then, India’s BASA with Qatar must be of net benefit to India. By pulling out of the Transit Agreement, India would be able to negotiate forcefully with Qatar and get an agreement that could limit Qatar Airways’ 6th Freedom operations and its interloper practices. This is because if an India-Qatar BASA could not be negotiated on terms completely satisfactory to India, India could tear up the BASA and subsequently be able to force Qatar Airways to cancel or dramatically re-route flights between Doha and Thailand, the Philippines, Malaysia and Singapore, and possible other destinations depending on prevailing wind patterns.

Any actions by the Government of India that limited the interloper actions of Qatar Airways would be boost to the India-United States BASA and increase the number of nonstop flights between two of the world’s most important democracies.

Conclusion

Under the prevailing circumstances, it is clear that India-United States relations are going to improve very significantly, very soon. Their shared interests, their desire to forge closer ties, the need for better collaboration will spur the need for increased travel between the two States. The question for the Indian government is what measures it will adopt to ensure that the lion’s share of traffic between India and the United States is carried by American and Indian airlines on non-stop flights between the two States.

India’s greatest power is in her people, but the geographic power granted by the expanse of her territory cannot be underestimated. It can be artfully used, as Canada has learned, to update a flawed BASA in the interests of the stronger more important State.


* P. Paul Fitzgerald (MBA, DCL, FRAeS, FCILT) is an Adjunct Professor at the Institute of Air & Space Law, McGill University, Canada.

References:

[1] These are Government-Backed Mega Carriers based in the UAE and Qatar. All of them are focused on bringing Indians to Europe and North America. See Peter Paul Fitzgerald, A Level Playing Field for “Open Skies”: the Need for Consistent Aviation Regulation, (The Hague: Eleven International Publishing, 2016) pp. 2, 105-109 & 286.

[2] ‘Britain to end Bermuda Agreement’, Flight International, 3 July 1976, p. 4.

[3] This routing was chosen to show how unlikely this route is; Bucharest has never seen a trans-Atlantic flight and Omaha has never seen a regularly scheduled flight from another country!

[4] This list is compiled from DATA in Airlines schedules, such as the Narita Airport International Flight Schedule (1-31 October 2023), and the schedules for American Airlines, Cargo Widebody Flight Schedule 1-30 September 2023, Delta Cargo, International Flight Schedule November 2023 and for United Cargo Widebody Schedule October 2023.

[5] This list is compiled from DATA in Airlines schedules, such as American Airlines, Cargo Widebody Flight Schedule 1-30 September 2023, and United Cargo Widebody Schedule October 2023. The eight routes are Chicago-Delhi, Newark-Mumbai, Washington-Delhi, New York to each of Delhi and Mumbai and from San Francisco to each of Bengaluru, Delhi and Mumbai.

[6] Supra note 1.

[7] Ibid.

[8] This includes the 332.000 Qatari citizens, who are roughly

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *