Jessica Los Banos*
Keywords: Access to Space Initiative – Democratizing access – New Space – Province of all mankind – Sustainable development
Introduction
Recognizing the pragmatic reality that not all States can be space-faring nations is the first step to ensuring that international cooperation delivers on its promise of access to space for all. Rather than aiming to compete in the provision of launch services, the servicing of commercial nanosatellite constellations, or the emerging cislunar space segment which are dominated by entrenched players like the United States and China, developing countries with little or no capability to participate in space activities must instead leverage collaborative opportunities from open-access space technologies and applications as a sensible strategy for socio-economic development. Presence in outer space is not per se the enabler of growth; instead, access to space-based solutions is key to ensuring sustainable development. In its 2021 Exploring Space Technologies for Sustainable Development report, the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) has noted that while use of space technologies, such as satellite Earth observation, communications, navigation, and positioning to address food security issues, deliver education services, build smarter cities, cope with disasters, and reduce poverty have become ubiquitous, bottlenecks persist that prevent developing countries from exploiting these technologies, including a basic lack of awareness concerning benefits, and the technology and skills gap to develop, use and adapt them. To address these constraints, it endorsed international efforts at promoting access through collaborations for capacity-building.
Understanding Capacity-Building
Capacity-building is defined broadly as “the process of developing and strengthening the skills, instincts, abilities, processes and resources that organizations and communities need to survive, adapt, and thrive in a fast-changing world”. There is common consensus that capacity-building is critical in supporting developing countries to achieve their sustainable development goals (SDGs). However, there is a need to revisit and reframe the conventional narrative centered around perceived and apparent lack of know-how and resources in this age of deep space missions and artificial intelligence. Emerging technologies including satellite communications and its derivative applications such as web search engines, AI and Internet of Things (IoT) are said to be “the future of everything” and are increasingly made available to the public through open source arrangements. It is therefore timely and essential to challenge the popular assumption that development assistance is the primary means to enable developing countries to steepen their learning curves and to cut the time to apply technology-driven solutions, particularly considering that information and data sets have become increasingly available for learning, benchmarking, baselining, strategic planning and implementation purposes.“Development is a comprehensive process involving economic as well as social and environmental changes” and developing countries must adapt and change to keep pace with revolutionary and emerging technological advancements. Development assistance can only work in a good policy environment, where there are improvements in economic institutions and policies, complemented by private investment, with a “focus on ideas and not money” that produce tangible and measurable results. Accordingly, capacity-building should be “repackaged” to enable both public and private sectors to undertake constant innovation to harness open access space and emerging technologies and ensure their deployment in much needed reforms that are sustained beyond one-time pilot initiatives.
The Outer Space Treaty’s “Benefit and Interest” Mandate
Capacity-building is intrinsically entrenched in the 1967 Outer Space Treaty, which transformed the principles on the peaceful and responsible use of outer space into legal obligations. Article I lays down the need for respecting the benefit and interest principle by stating that “the exploration and use of outer space, including the moon and other celestial bodies, shall be carried out for the benefit and in the interests of all countries, irrespective of their degree of economic or scientific development, and shall be the province of all mankind.” The twin principles of “benefit and interests” and “province of all mankind” indicate the importance of collaboration in scientific research and space technology development. This is further supplemented by the emphasis on international cooperation under Articles I, III, IX, X, XI and XII of the Outer Space Treaty. Hence, the Outer Space Treaty reflects the duty to provide capacity-building assistance to less-developed countries to explore and use outer space, and lays down the foundation for international partnerships in space activities. As space technologies developed by first-movers facilitate provision of ideas, data and solutions, developing countries, with the cooperation from developed states, become better equipped to craft for themselves effective strategies and programs tailored to their technology absorption capacities and sustainable development challenges.
Democratizing Access to Outer Space for Developing-Country Actors and Activities
While the scope, content and the extent of the “benefit and interest” and “province” principles, and the intensity and inclusivity of capacity-building assistance are open to debate, space-capable nations are delivering on their obligations by democratizing access to outer space. For example, the availability of Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) and other space-based services offering free mass-market access for position, navigation, and timing is “creating unprecedented opportunity, bringing benefits in the areas of emergency management, marine and land monitoring, or fleet control to name a few”. The democratization of access to outer space is a progressive concept that represents a departure from the historical dominance of space-faring nations that jealously guard intellectual property rights to protect national security, thus opening avenues for New Space actors from developing economies to actively use space technologies for sustainable development. New Space involves a paradigm shift towards a more accessible and inclusive space environment, where true to Outer Space Treaty’s vision for humanity, the benefits and opportunities associated with outer space activities may be seized by cost-sharing arrangements, public-private partnerships, and collaborative ventures, that overcome resource and know-how constraints beyond the development assistance model of capacity-building.
Two important initiatives promote New Space through cooperative multilateral arrangements. The United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs (UNOOSA)’s 2018 Access to Space Initiative is a forward-thinking program that offers access space research facilities, infrastructure and information, serving as a platform for developing countries to collaborate with space-faring nations and partner institutions for capacity-building. In parallel, its 2019 Space Law for New Space Actors Project complements the access initiative by providing a framework for space law to be tailored to the circumstances of the new space entrants. This project harmonizes state practice and spreads the benefits of space exploration while upholding the principles of international cooperation and responsible conduct in space. Buy-in is also assured as capacity-building assistance is by request. According to UNOOSA, this “contributes to raising global adherence to – and awareness of – the international and legal instruments applicable to outer space activities, for the benefit of established and emerging space-faring nations alike”. Non-profit organizations and academic institutions, such as the Secure World Foundation which released its Handbook for New Actors in Space and the USA-ISU’s (International Space University) Access to Space in the Southern Hemisphere, confirm the need for a new capacity-building model within the New Space framework.
Similarly, expansion of access to space technologies has remained a key priority on the agenda of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) since the 1950s. A review of resolutions on the international cooperation in the peaceful uses of outer space, often adopted without a vote by the UNGA, affirm member states’ conviction that use of space science and technology and their applications contribute to achieving the economic, social and cultural goals of developing economies. Its more recent resolutions in particular call for greater access to and use of space-based services and geo-spatial information and facilitating capacity-building and institutional strengthening for disaster management. In its 15 December 2022 resolution, the UNGA noted that progress has been achieved in fostering international cooperation and reiterated the importance of continuing to build capacity for developing countries to access and use space technologies particularly under the UN Programme on Space Applications.
Sustainability of Strategic Technology Deployment
Moving beyond access to space technologies and capacity building, developing countries must now grapple with the arduous undertaking of implementing their sustainable development agendas by strategically deploying these technologies for long-term benefits. Addressing the two concerns raised by the UNCTAD on the lack of awareness concerning benefits of space technologies and the skills to develop, use and adapt them through collaboration represents just the initial step flowing from collaborative capacity-building. In regard to bringing awareness of benefits of space technologies to developing countries, capacity-building activities, such as the forthcoming UN/Philippines Workshop on the Applications of Global Navigation Satellite Systems, must move beyond information-sharing and knowledge-building and emphasize the more difficult operational task of bringing solutions downstream through grassroots and ground deployment. Action plans entailing the identification of an initial project such as the use of drones and GNSS data for precision farming and entering into a preliminary agreement of regional cooperation between countries must be designed under the New Space paradigm. Likewise, addressing the skills gap to facilitate transfer of technology, knowledge, and expertise will require adjustments and improvements in the country’s education and training systems. Educating a cadre of scientists, engineers, and technicians is essential for the continuous deployment of space technologies and applications capable of undertaking research, development, and innovation in space-related activities. In the Philippines, a long-overdue pioneering aerospace degree at the Ateneo de Davao University is now on offer but other universities are yet to launch their own programs.
Moreover, “downstreaming” space technologies through collaboration must focus on the use and implementation of space technologies and should not be co-opted by issues of time, resource and knowledge necessary to establish a “space program or agency”. Instead, developing countries must design implementation mechanisms consistent with the New Space paradigm by establishing mediating bodies such as the United Kingdom’s Satellite Applications Catapult and the European Space Agency’s Downstream Gateway, which operate as ‘one-stop shop’ service for all downstream opportunities involving activities based on space technology, or using a space-derived system in a space or non-space environment, that may result in an application, product or service to the benefit of the economy or society, effectively creating links between new and emerging business sectors and the capabilities being developed by States. This strategy hurdles the commonly held belief that a space policy or agency is needed before space technologies can be used. More importantly, it facilitates the integration of the space sector with mainstream industries, particularly health, energy, resource management, information and communication, and transportation, which are critical for implementing their SDGs.
Conclusion
Accessible space technologies and the associated capacity-building resources are readily available to developing countries. They must however be implemented and deployed beyond assistance arrangements. To facilitate their enduring and sustained application for practical purposes and effective solutions across downstream industries for the benefit of stakeholders, developing countries must now embrace the new paradigm of collaborative capacity-building where commercialization of space technologies and applications can become catalysts for innovation and problem-solving tailored to their specific sustainable development needs.
* The author is a Foreign Lecturer at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Pelita Harapan, Indonesia.
