Karan Nimish Vakil*
Key Words: Aircraft Leasing – Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA) – GIFT City – Go First – Ireland
Indian commercial air carriers Air India and IndiGo commanded the lion’s share of attention at the recent biennial Paris Air Show as the former’s record order of 470 aircraft was outdone by the latter’s order of 500. India houses the fastest-growing commercial aviation market in the world. Given its geographical location and rapid construction of world-class aviation infrastructure, it has been long prophesized to become a global aviation hub, capable of rivalling the dominant commercial air carriers of the middle-east. As private players make strides towards making India into a global commercial aviation hub, the onus is now on the Government of India to take appropriate steps towards creating a positive business climate that its commercial air carriers will need to grow and prosper.
Contrary to popular belief, commercial airlines do not own all of the aircraft in their fleet. The fleet of most commercial airlines will likely consist of owned and leased aircraft, with the latter outnumbering the former. Aircraft leasing is not dissimilar from the leasing of any other capital-intensive asset insomuch that it simply involves the leasing of the asset (in this case, aircraft) by the lessor to the lessee for a fixed and limited duration of time in exchange for monthly rental payments. Leasing is done to alleviate the financial burden of buying aircraft, and thus, to simultaneously increase the flying capacity of the commercial airline. For context, a single airbus A320 neo aircraft, which dominates Indigo’s current fleet, would cost approximately USD 110 million to buy but approximately USD 300,000 to lease per month. Thus, with a given amount of capital, more aircraft can be leased than bought at a given point of time. Statistically, over half of the world’s aircraft used for commercial purposes are owned by leasing companies, who then lease these aircraft to commercial airlines. For example, over 80% of Indigo and SpiceJet’s respective fleets comprise of leased Aircraft. This percentage is currently far lower for Air India, (standing at 40%) but will soon change over the next few years as a larger portion of the 470 aircraft get delivered on lease, rather than on an ownership basis.
Only a handful of jurisdictions have recognized and capitalized on the leasing structure that dominates aircraft transactions worldwide. Of these jurisdictions, Ireland has been and continues to be the global capital for aircraft lessors to operate from. Notably, Ireland’s Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA) are crafted to relieve aircraft lessors of certain tax payments due in the jurisdiction that the aircraft operates from. India’s own DTAA with Ireland allows for “Profits derived by an enterprise of a Contracting State from the operation or rental of ships or aircraft in international traffic and the rental of containers and related equipment which is incidental to the operation of ships or aircraft in international traffic shall be taxable only in that Contracting State” under Article 8(1).
Consequent to the above provision, rental payments received by aircraft lessors situated in Ireland from Indian commercial air carriers such as Air India, Indigo, SpiceJet etc. for use of aircraft are not taxed at source in India. This is then coupled with further domestic tax benefits for aircraft lessors situate in Ireland, cumulatively resulting in tax payments amounting to a fraction of what would have been payable outside Ireland, that is, if the aircraft lessor had been a tax resident elsewhere. In turn, benefits for Ireland come in the more obvious forms of economic development stimulation, increased employment, resource development and transfer etc., as would be the envisioned outcome of any species of foreign direct investment. The country that the aircraft is leased into and operates from, by entering into a DTAA with Ireland, is able to attract aircraft lessors to lease aircraft into the country, thereby stimulating the growth of the commercial aviation sector, and also the economy as a whole. It is noteworthy here that the commercial aviation sector currently contributes to as much as 5% of India’s gross domestic product, creating 4 million jobs in the process.
The Government of India has recently taken a bold step towards attempting to challenge Ireland’s place as the global haven for aircraft lessors. With a view to facilitating the initiation of aircraft leasing business from India, the Government has notified ‘Aircraft lease’ as a financial product under Section 3(1)(d) of the International Financial Services Centre Act 2019, thereby, providing various tax incentives to foreign aircraft lessors to relocate to or set up Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) at the Special Economic Zone (SEZ) of Gujarat International Finance Tec (GIFT) City.
Aircraft lessors intending to avail themselves of the SEZ at GIFT City may do so by first establishing a local company, limited liability partnership or a trust with a prescribed minimum capital requirement, the quantum of which depends on the type of aircraft lease that the entity enters into as lessor of the aircraft. Aircraft leases are broadly categorized into finance leases and operating leases. While in the case of finance leases, the ownership of the asset may pass to the lessee at the end of the lease term, in the case of operating leases, the ownership is retained by the lessor at the end of the lease term. The minimum capital requirement for an entity intending to lease aircraft by way of a finance lease is USD 3 million, and for an entity intending to lease aircraft by way of an operating lease in USD 200,000.
As far as tax benefits are concerned, some of the most appealing reductions are in the form of a 10 year consecutive tax holiday under the Income Tax Act 1961, no goods and service tax (GST) on services received under the Central Goods and Services Act 2017, exemption from customs duty under the Customs Act 1962 for all goods imported for authorized operations, and exemption from stamp duty and registration charges under the Gujarat Stamp Act 1958.
While Indian lessors such as JetSetGo and Vman Aero have begun small scale leasing operations from the SEZ at GIFT City, foreign lessors are yet to substantially deviate from Ireland and give the Indian setup a chance. Recently, a foreign lessor entered into an aircraft lease agreement with Air India, which involved a head-lease – sub-lease structure; this structure contemplated a head-lease between the foreign lessor and Air India and a sub-lease between Air India and its SPV (AI Fleet Services Limited) at GIFT City. Indigo is also to set up a SPV at GIFT City in preparedness for similarly structured transactions. However, no foreign lessor has yet set up an SPV at GIFT City. Given that it is primarily foreign lessors that own and lease the larger aircraft that market dominant commercial air carriers such as Air India, Indigo and SpiceJet operate, it is fair to say that the SEZ at GIFT City is yet to make its mark on the Indian commercial aviation sector.
Foreign lessors remain apprehensive of doing business in India on account of several factors such as the nascency of the SEZ at GIFT City, scarcity of banks that are willing to finance transactions through the SEZ at GIFT City, and most recently, the ongoing corporate insolvency resolution process of Go First. Go First, India’s fourth largest airline by market share had been struggling inter alia due to malfunctioning engines supplied by American aerospace manufacturer Pratt & Whitney, which resulted in the forced grounding of the majority of its fleet. The airline recently filed an application for voluntary insolvency before the National Company Law Tribunal, New Delhi, setting off a chain reaction that has left aircraft lessors unable to repossess their own aircraft. This has left foreign aircraft lessors with an extremely sceptical outlook towards doing business in India.
India now finds itself at a crucial juncture on its path to becoming a formidable player in the global aviation industry. It is imperative for the Government of India to showcase a robust and uncomplicated business environment by addressing the concerns of foreign aircraft lessors so as to allow foreign direct investment via the SEZ at GIFT City to flow and the Indian commercial aviation sector to burgeon.
* The Author is an Associate at Tyabji Dayabhai, Advocates & Solicitors.
