Kanchan Yadav*
Keywords: Airport Governance Toolkit – Airports Authority of India – Climate change – Paris Agreement – Zero emission
Background
Effects of climate change are no longer far-off consequences of human actions; rather, they are extremely visible in the modern society. As per 2019 statistics, global warming had already reached a level of 1.1 degrees Celsius increase above the pre-industrial period. In 2023, the figure reached a whopping 2.45 degrees Celsius increase. The average temperature of the decade ending with 2019 was the highest ever recorded, with severe reduction in polar ice levels and rise in sea levels. Thirty percent of the world’s population is now subject to deadly temperature conditions for more than twenty days every year.
In the Paris Agreement 2015, the global community came to a legally binding commitment to ensure that the global temperature does not rise beyond 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. To ensure that, pledges were made to decrease the individual nations’ greenhouse gas emissions in a progressive manner till 2030, or till a goal of net zero emission is reached. However, because of non-compliance up till this point, the nations now have a rather high goal of almost 8% reduction in emissions every year to be on the 2°C road. If another five years pass at the current pace, the goal would reach to an almost impossible level of almost 16% reduction.
Broadly speaking, the two biggest culprits behind global warming and climate change are CO2 (primarily obtained from burning fossil fuels) and Methane (primarily used in the cooling industry). While Methane is deadlier in a small amount, its impacts dwarf compared to CO2, which is produced by almost every human activity. One of the primary sectors which contribute to carbon emission is civil aviation.
Emission reductions in the civil aviation industry need to come together from two different areas – airlines and aerodromes. On the one hand, the airline industry needs to reduce its carbon emissions through innovations in engine and fuel, on the other hand, airports need to equip themselves with the necessary infrastructure and technology that would reduce their own emissions and have positive impacts on the airlines’ efforts as well. Taking that into account, the International Air Transport Association (IATA) has called for a target of net zero emissions for all member airlines and airports. However, considering the global lax attitude towards sustainability in the previous decades, the level of compliance with such objectives needs to be enquired into.
Sustainability in Civil Aviation – Efforts of IATA
IATA is a non-governmental global association, comprising of major airlines across the world. Founded in 1945, the IATA currently has 317 member airlines from more than 120 countries. The overall membership of IATA covers around 83% of all civil aviation worldwide. It describes the mission of the association as “working together to shape the future growth of a safe, secure and sustainable air transport industry that connects and enriches our world”.
In the recent years, the IATA has shown a strong move towards sustainability. The overarching objective regarding the same is to ensure that global civil aviation reaches net zero emission by 2050. While aspects such as the sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) and Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (CORSIA) are to be implemented in the context of airlines, the IATA has been greatly vocal about the need for airports to reach net zero emission as well. It has mentioned that sustainability should be at the core of airport planning, from the time of conception to improvement of existing infrastructure and technology. The goal, ultimately, is to build ‘green airports’, so that there can be the “greatest possible reduction in the air transport industry’s overall carbon footprint in the most efficient way”.
To facilitate the same, IATA’s Airport Governance Toolkit provides dedicated steps to be taken towards airport sustainability. The Toolkit provides a description of five primary domains with respect to airport governance, with Community and Environment being one of them. This domain, in particular, focuses on sustainability and environmental issues with respect to noise, air quality, and water and waste management. Moreover, it emphasizes upon the need for the decision makers considering all aspects of sustainability in airport governance, while enacting relevant regulations and changes.
Other than the Airport Governance Toolkit, the IATA also periodically publishes an Airport Development Reference Manual. In its current version the Manual identifies primarily four components of sustainability that airport development should focus on. They are; the reduction of CO2 emissions, the reduction of NOx and other missions, reduction of noise, and sustainable land use, to ensure a balance of interests among the passengers, society, economy, and environment.
The first of such elements is the design of the airport. While the individual design of each airport would vary based on the passenger and aircraft movement requirements and capacities; the physical layout of the terminal, buildings, taxiways, and runways impact the overall sustainability of the airport. Another important aspect of sustainability, as highlighted in the Manual, is the reduction in emissions – which can be facilitated by modifying road and public transport access to the airport and discouraging the usage of private vehicles over public transport. Energy consumption and usage would also be an important element towards building a green airport, which would consist of using energy-efficient technology, energy conservation via automated temperature control, and implementation of temperature control methods.
Overall, the various documents published by the IATA highlight the crucial role that airports play in reducing overall carbon emissions and other unsustainable practices associated with civil aviation. Other than design and infrastructure related steps, this would also include initiatives such as green investments, appropriate resource management, and better collaboration among various stakeholders in airside operations.
The GAU Story: Compliance Status
While the IATA has been proactive in providing steps to make its goal of net zero emissions by 2050 a reality, all of it would be futile without such recommendations being implemented by the concerned national, state, and local governments. In the Indian context, it is true that there has been a considerable amount of efforts towards reducing emissions from airports and supporting other sustainable practices. However, the reality of the tier 1 international airports starkly varies from that of the airports in tier 2 cities. An exploration of the Lokpriya Gopinath Bordoloi Airport (GAU) in Guwahati would confirm the same.
The GAU airport was established in 1958, as one of the first airports in the north-east region of India. The Airport has a capacity of serving 20,000 passengers at once and 6 million annually, a figure that was almost reached in 2023, with 5.6 million passengers served during the year. The airport currently has one terminal, but considering the increased footfall, the construction of a second terminal is underway since 2018. The new terminal will be able to serve an additional 10 million passengers.
Since work on the second terminal started, there has been a great deal of buzz about the new terminal being the ‘most sustainable airport terminal’ in the northeast region of India. It was claimed that it will have several sustainable features such as sewage treatment, waste management, rainwater harvesting, solar energy, energy-saving lighting, etc. Similarly, the area inside and outside the airport will be adorned by plantation areas and local flora. However, the tall claims start to fall apart, when examined closely.
To begin with, an analysis of the claims made by the Airports Authority of India, taken along with the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report of the new terminal, gives the impression that the sustainability initiatives regarding the new terminal are simply tactics to appease the public, and not genuine in nature. While the new terminal, set to be inaugurated in 2024, might be the most sustainable of all airports in the northeast, that is not a high bar. The outlined initiatives such as energy saving lights, sewage treatments, etc. are extremely basic technologies that have been available for many years. Implementing the same is not out of the ordinary, in fact, it would be concerning if such measures were not implemented at this juncture. Moreover, considering how they are often mentioned together along with other passenger and tourist attractions such as several lifts and elevators, craft fairs inside the Airport, etc., establish such initiatives more strongly as a publicity mechanism.
Additionally, the EIA highlights several areas where there will be environmental impacts due to the new terminal – including aspects such as land use, water consumption and quality, air quality, noise level, and ecology. However, no solid steps to offset these unavoidable impacts are provided, other than stating that efforts will be taken to minimize the impacts as much as possible. There is also no mention by the authorities of a more measurable goal, which is the reduction of carbon emissions or reaching net zero standards. The aspect of ensuring sustainability through the physical layout and design of the Airport, which has the potential to significantly aid aircraft in their emission reduction, is conveniently absent as well.
What Next?
It is not that the efforts undertaken by the GAU Airport authorities are incorrect per se. After all, the pathway to a sustainable and net zero airport would surely include steps such as solar energy production, efficient energy consumption, and adequate waste management. However, the problem lies with the severe lack of planning that the authorities have shown throughout the process. The first step towards creating a sustainable airport, as highlighted in the Airports Council International (ACI) Airport Carbon Accreditation program, is to measure the footprint of the relevant airport. As of now, no comprehensive measurement of the carbon and environmental footprint of the overall airport as well as of the new terminal has been done. Without the same, any sustainability effort undertaken would be akin to walking blind.
Any evaluation of the overall environmental impact of the airport must include aspects such as emissions, noise, water quality, resource consumption, energy efficiency, and waste management. By measuring the environmental impacts in such quantifiable manner, a sustainability-based scorecard model may be implemented to ensure sustainable development of airports. An appropriate example of taking such quantifiable data and implementing relevant measures based on the same would be the Zero Net Energy Plan of the San Francisco International Airport (SFO). The first step that the authorities took was to map out the campus of the airport, and develop a plan on how to reduce energy consumption and achieve zero net energy. The plan outlined the steps necessary to reduce consumption as well as to integrate renewable energy to achieve the ultimate goal.
With the new terminal of the GAU Airport set to be inaugurated in the next few months, the best time to conduct such an environmental analysis was perhaps be in 2018, when the construction began. However, the next best time to do so would be now. With the terminal almost complete, the likely emissions and other environmental impacts will be easily measurable, and accordingly, relevant measures might be designed to reduce and offset the same. While the IATA provides exemplary guideline documents on how to achieve the same, ultimately, they merely provide guidance and IATA has no authority to force compliance upon airport administrators. Thus, it is up to the relevant authorities and stakeholders, including the Airports Authority of India, to ensure that necessary and measurable steps with respect to sustainability, and not just publicity stunts, are taken by the airport administration.
* The author is an Academic Fellow at the WB National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata, and a Ph.D. candidate at National Law School of India University, Bengaluru.
