Kaushik H.M.*
Keywords: Jurisdiction – Outer Space Treaty – Property rights – Res communis – Res nullius
Introduction
It is perhaps a tragedy of the human condition that governing nature has been an easier task when compared to governing human behaviour. The rate of evolution of technology has always outpaced changes in legal and ethical norms; labour laws could never keep up with industrialization, and privacy laws are still playing catch up to data science. As the degradation of Earth continues for various reasons including technological ones, there is an emerging intersection between science and politics. Space exploration is one such intersection.
The exploration of space is not only an act of adventure but also one of survival. Along with numerous ethical conundrums, space exploration poses great legal challenges. If space ought to be accessible to the whole of humanity, there needs to be a way for the international community to overcome its fragmented nature (if at all that is possible). This write-up tries to investigate the relationship between nation-states, sovereignty and space exploration. It aims to make three arguments in this context. First, that the current position of international law which bars nation-states from claiming sovereignty in space is unlikely to hold its ground for too long. Second, that there is a strong relationship between property rights and sovereignty which international law cannot separate. Finally, that there is a possibility of establishing a harmony between interests of nation-states in space with the collective interests of the human community.
Current Position of International Law
Outer Space Treaty, 1967 is the most significant treaty concerning space exploration. Article I of the Treaty lays down the purpose for which nation-states can explore outer space. It states that exploration must be conducted for the benefit of all countries regardless of the extent of their economic and scientific development. The essential inference from this Article being that parties to the Treaty agree that space is res communis or a variant of it, that is, belonging to everyone, and not res nullius, that is, belonging to no one. This doctrinal distinction has major ramifications for the trajectory of international space law as both these doctrines signify some form of commonality among humans in their relationship with space but differ in regards to the basis of their commonality. This leads us to a significant question: if space belongs to everyone, who has sovereignty over it? Article II of the Outer Space treaty exclusively denies nation states to make any claim of sovereignty. If sovereignty refers to the exclusive, ultimate authority within a territory; does it then follow that any demarcation of territory in outer space for practical purposes would make claims of sovereignty inevitable?
Before addressing this question, let us look at the development of the law of the seas, which also began its journey on the premise of res communis.
The Law of Seas and Space Exploration
The earliest claim of sovereignty in the seas was made in the decrees passed by Pope Alexander after the discovery of various sea routes by Columbus. The decrees stated that one part of the discovery would belong to Spain and the other to Portugal. In opposition to the decree and perhaps to enable the English to sail in waters, it is believed that it was Queen Elizabeth I who first proclaimed that the seas are free to all nations. With the subsequent work of Grotius among others, there was a growing international consensus regarding the free nature of the seas. However, with the emergence of nation-states and stronger naval powers, protection of territorial integrity took primacy over freedom of the seas. This led to nations claiming sovereignty over a part of the seas around their land. Many international conflicts today are conflicts concerning the sovereignty over seas, something which nation-states realize is beneficial for strategic purposes as well as for the massive access to resources which the seas provide.
This partial transition of the seas from the domain of res communis to the domain of sovereignty is of great value in our study of international space law. As space exploration is at its infancy, self-interest of nation states is currently hidden behind technological constraints. The moment extraction of resources and its transportation from outer space to Earth becomes a scientific reality, nation-states will find a strong nexus between exploration of space and fulfilling their obligations to citizens. This argument is strengthened by the current international practice around satellites. Article VIII of the Outer Space Treaty permits states to retain control over any object registered in that state, including satellites, however, recent developments in the governance of international telecommunication suggests that states can also appropriate (though in practical terms) the entire orbital space in which the satellites orbit the Earth. Essentially, this creates a causal chain between the ownership of objects and its purpose, and subsequently a claim over space itself, if it is sufficiently tied to the said purpose.
This brings us to the next question, can having jurisdiction over objects, persons and events in space be construed as having sovereignty in space?
Jurisdiction and Sovereignty
The current position of international law with regards to jurisdiction and sovereignty in outer space is clear; states have jurisdiction over objects and persons belonging to the state (rationeinstrumenti and ratione personae) but have no claim of sovereignty. However, there are gaps in the current law that allows for claims of jurisdiction to turn into a backdoor entry for claims of sovereignty. For instance, Article 9 of the Moon Agreement, 1979 allows for preservation of manned and unmanned stations by merely “notifying” the UN Secretary-General. Though there is also a mandate to limit the use of area on Moon to only fulfil the “needs of the station”, the introduction of a subjective element like “need” is likely to allow states to gain control over areas far beyond what the law intends to permit. This problem would magnify when stations of multiple nations are placed close by, perhaps near a resource rich site. The only way to resolve conflicts arising out of such circumstances would be to then make territorial demarcations of some kind. Now, let us add all these elements together; if there is a marked territory on a celestial body, a population of astronauts, governance of the territory and personnel, and consensus with other nations who want to make similar claims, we end up fulfilling all the criteria needed for statehood as laid down in the Montevideo Convention,1933.
This transition from jurisdictional control to territorial control is a real possibility that international space law has not yet contended with.
Property Rights and Sovereignty
In the previous section, we have investigated the relationship between jurisdiction and sovereignty, in this section we will take a different starting point.
It is important to note that Article II of the Outer Space Treaty which prohibits nation-states from having any form of ownership on celestial bodies, does not clarify its position of individual appropriation of celestial bodies. If states themselves do not have ownership, do they have any right to stop individuals from making ownership claims? The supreme court of U.S had to answer the same in Nemitz v. United States, wherein the appellant claimed ownership over an asteroid based on the premise that he had asserted his natural right over an unowned property through an online registration platform, and thereby, could sue the government for landing a space object on the asteroid without his permission. The state in response argued that neither was there any constitutional or statutory basis for his argument nor was there any use and occupation of the territory to create any real interest in the property. Conversely, it would mean that use and occupation of land along with a natural right to do so would be the necessary conditions for possessing property rights on celestial bodies. All unclaimed territory on Earth is claimed through the same means, or as John Locke would argue, mixing one’s labour with property would create rights in it as everyone is entitled to fruits of their own labour. This leads us to another significant question; on what basis does international law make a distinction between unclaimed territory on Earth and in outer space? If there is no material and philosophical distinction between Earth and other celestial bodies, there is an argument to be made to perceive celestial bodies as a mere extension of Earth severed by the vacuum of space in between, similar to how nations and continents are separated only by the intervention of water bodies.
It is necessary for international law scholars to address these philosophical questions to strengthen the laws position on private property rights in space, an issue that is likely to arise when private organizations like SpaceX and Blue Origin get closer to realizing their dream of extensive commercial space tourism and laying their hands on celestial bodies.
Conclusion
The tension between the doctrine of res communis and the object of space exploration is not illusory and international law must not pretend that it is. There is no good reason to believe that international law can prevent the transmission of ideas such as national sovereignty and capitalism to outer space for the simple fact that they are human enterprises and not mere territorial particularities. The more pragmatic goal for international law would be to create laws and institutions which would minimize the harms of these enterprises. This may include formation of multinational authorities that give substantial decision-making power to members from less developed countries, separation of space colonies from origin state, training of astronauts from diverse regional backgrounds, conditional resource extraction, resource sharing policies and so on.
* Affiliated Institution: Jindal Global Law School, Sonipat.
