ICAO’s Approach to Address Aviation Pollution: A Critical Analysis

Dr. Aruna Kammila*

Keywords:  Civil Aviation Policy – CORSIA – DGCA – ICAO – Standards and Recommended Practices (SARPs)

Introduction

The aviation sector represents one of the most essential and profitable businesses in the contemporary world. This soaring industry commands nearly 3.6% of the world’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP), exhibiting the industry’s importance to the modern economy. It is projected to see massive growth in the coming years. It provides for over 65 million jobs worldwide, equivalent to the entire population and the economy of the United Kingdom. Human civilisation has come so far that we have found innovative and more efficient ways to travel worldwide and keep the global supply chain running rust-free.

India has been a growing force in the civil aviation arena and is amongst the fastest-growing markets in the world. The Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA) and the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) are India’s governing and regulatory authorities for this domain. Around $35 billion has been contributed to the nation’s GDP by this sector already in the past. It is expected to grow more, thanks to the enhanced connectivity due to the ‘UDAN’ scheme, which is mandated to enable affordable access to air travel and improve the economic condition of the country.The National Civil Aviation Policy 2016 has been hailed as a robust policy, although it is not the first ever ‘post-independence’ civil aviation policy. The policy aims to provide affordable air travel to all citizens and helps in constructing and reviving airstrips to improve access to air travel.

However, the policy is not free from loopholes as it failed to discuss or mention one of the most pressing issues, environmental impact and sustainability. Notably, none of the international organisations has made any ‘substantive’ progress in addressing this issue. The International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) passed a resolution in its 41st session in Montréal, which acknowledged the shortcomings in the progress made concerning the reduction in CO2 (carbon dioxide) emissions. ICAO has also made a compulsion to the member states to make efforts in the progress of aircraft technologies, operational improvements, and sustainable aviation fuels.

Impact of SARPs

The Standards and Recommended Practices (SARPs) are guidelines issued and adopted by the ICAO to address the different issues of civil aviation by ensuring uniformity in the standards and regulations.Article 38 of the Convention on International Civil Aviation (Chicago Convention) states that the Member States should notify the ICAO in case they find the provisions impractical to comply with or to bring their standards in conformity with SARPs.

One such SARP is in the form of Annex 16 of the Chicago Convention, referred to as the ‘Environmental Protection’, which has addressed three key areas. First, aircraft noise, for which the Annex provides guidelines for controlling and reducing aircraft noise, particularly during takeoff and landing. It recommends using quieter aircraft technology, noise abatement procedures, and the establishment of noise certification standards for aircraft engines and airframes. The second issue is the emissions from aircraft engines, where the development and usage of environment friendly engine technology, such as low-emission engines, have been encouraged by the ICAO. Finally, fuel efficiency is the other issue addressed, wherein it is aimed towards reducing harmful emissions and encouraging the use of operational practices such as strategic air traffic management and reduction in the aircraft’s weight.

The national aviation authorities of the Member States are responsible for implementing these standards within their respective jurisdictions. They must work closely with airlines, aircraft manufacturers, and other stakeholders to enforce the recommended practices and monitor progress towards environmental goals. However, the SARPs lack the legally binding power, which their parent Convention enjoys. They are worded as recommendations to the Member States in case they want to follow to amplify their safety and sustainability standards.

Annex 16 of the Convention on International Civil Aviation provides an important approach to addressing the noise pollution issue that emerges from aircraft operations. The approach is directed towards reducing noise at the source. By observing this approach, specific measures such as imposing an ‘airport curfew’ would be reasonable to reduce the effects of noise pollution caused by aircraft, as far as the concerned airport is domestic since they are pretty much isolated from the complexities arising due to time zones and national borders. However, the curfew policy would adversely restrict international airports due to the flights flying across domestic borders. For example, a flight scheduled from the United Kingdom cannot be restricted in Indian airports based on their international nature, different time zones and different jurisdictions.

Even though the SARPs are yet to be enacted in municipal laws of the member states, it is remarkable that they do impact the aviation industry and their approach to addressing the issue at hand. Annex 16 has led to the establishment of the Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (CORSIA), a one-of-a-kind market standard developed intending to address the impact on the environment due to aviation emissions. It was introduced in the ICAO Assembly’s 39th session in 2016.

In the development process of SARP regulations, several airlines have made an effort with their sustainable aviation fuels and operations. For instance, Air France-KLM launched the first long-haul flight using sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), a biofuel manufactured completely in France’s refineries on 18 May 2021. Air France’s newest Airbus A350-900 sailed from Paris to Montreal, the world’s civil aviation centre, using a fuel combination that included 16% sustainable fuel, preventing 20 tonnes of CO2 emission, which clearly shows that the efforts are been made by the industries towards achieving environmental sustainability.

Under the ‘Air France ACT’ a programme aimed at reducing CO2 emissions per passenger-kilometer by 30% by 2030 compared to 2019, two of its flights left Paris-Charles de Gaulle, one to Montreal on 3 May 2022, and the other to Lisbon on 4 May 2022. The ICAO Council amended several international aviation environmental rules in March 2023 as it continues to make progress during its 228th session. A new addition to Annex 16 of the Chicago Convention clarifies the ICAO’s CORSIA monitoring, reporting, and verification responsibilities.

The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) 1997, based on the Kyoto Protocol, establishes its objectives in reduction of emissions of greenhouse gases but fails to address the international aviation emissions and the economic expenditure of the Member States in controlling carbon emissions.  Accordingly, the ICAO General Assembly has introduced CORSIA to tackle these issues which were not addressed in UNFCCC. Paragraph 9 of Resolution A41-22 of the ICAO called for a phased implementation of the CORSIA as it is aimed at accommodating “the special circumstances and respective capabilities of States, in particular developing States while minimising market distortion.”

Certain nations such as India have taken the initiative to enforce the said SARPs by welcoming the Airport Carbon Accreditation, where the aim is to reduce carbon emissions. The Delhi International Airport Limited (DIAL), for example, has showcased massive progress in the same, showcasing their potential and commitment to turn ‘net zero carbon emission’ airport by 2030.

To decarbonize the Indian aviation sector by 2050, a variety of initiatives are required, including fleet renewal with efficient flights, operational improvements in Air Traffic Management (ATM), and the usage of a SAF-ATF blend. Furthermore, the widespread use of TaxiBots to handle air-taxing at Indian airports will significantly induce Member States to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Meanwhile, research in electrification and hydrogen fuel is required to develop aircraft solutions. The government should offer sufficient funding to stimulate research and pilot studies on SAF manufacturing techniques and diverse locally accessible feed stocks.

Shortcomings of the Ongoing Efforts

The Kyoto Protocol 1997 has mandated the GHG emissions, but there were no goals set on controlling the emissions due to the global aviation industry. Even though the Member States were working to achieve the goals of Kyoto Protocol in other sectors, there was tremendous increase in aviation emissions. Hence, the ICAO acted as a guiding factor for the Member States in controlling international aviation emissions. In the year 1999, The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has prepared a report which underlined and identified the need to have more rigid engine regulations and for the removal of subsidies and incentives which would harm the environment. Thus, the report published by the IPCC has highlighted the shortcomings with respect to global climate change framework.

The ICAO has also failed to come up with ‘concrete’ solutions which would help mitigate the problem. It has been working along with its Member States to inflate its mandate to include the mitigation of climate change due to the aviation industry. In this effort, the ICAO has interpreted its parent legislation in a way that empowers itself to regulate GHG emissions without an explicit mention of mitigation of climate change. However, the absence of the said mention does flare up when fixing accountability.

As mentioned above, CORSIA was introduced by the ICAO to fill-in the gaps of the Kyoto Protocol. It allows the airlines to emit a certain amount of carbon but with a condition to invest in purchase of carbon offsets. However, ICAO has failed to implement the regulatory framework of environment by not strictly restricting the emissions of the aviation industry. Thus by allowing partially to emit carbon into the atmosphere coupled with the failure to have a proper regulatory framework, the danger has been only reduced rather than eliminated by ICAO.

Conclusion

The aviation industry is a booming sector which is expected to handle a billion passengers per annum in the coming years. Being an industry commanding around 3.6% of the global GDP, it must implement sustainability effectively. The decarbonization of the routes regarding aviation industry can be done by proper use and implementation of CORSIA and use of SAF. To achieve a better segregation and supply chain mechanisms for the steady supply of SAF, aviation business must aim for research and development of cost-effective SAF. The environmental concerns of civil aviation can be solved only by ensuring a constant supply of the SAF on a massive scale. Such large-scale production can reduce the overall cost and make it at par with the cost of the commonly used aviation turbine fuel.

Given the fact that the aviation sector is one of the biggest factors for climate change and GHG emissions, ICAO should address the issue of mitigating climate change explicitly to bring accountability to the table. The responsibility of Member States concerning the compliance of the guidelines needs emphasis to better handle the situation.


* The author is an Associate Professor at ICFAI Law School, ICFAI University, Hyderabad, Telangana.

Initial Thoughts on a Possible Regime for Space Traffic Management

Yun ZHAO*

Keywords:      Registration – Soft law – Space safety – Space traffic management – Sustainability

With the rapid development of space technologies, space tourism and transportation have become a reality and will continue to thrive in the process of space commercialization and privatization. It is obvious to all that the existing space law rules cannot meet the needs of future space transportation. It is time to seriously consider a possible legal regime to deal with space traffic management to ensure the safety of spacecraft in orbit and avoid potential collisions or accidents.

Space traffic management has a broad scope, covering the whole period from pre-launch, operation to re-entry of space objects. Space traffic management is defined by the International Academy of Astronautics (IAA) as “the set of technical and regulatory provisions for promoting safe access into outer space, operations in outer space and return from outer space to Earth free from physical or radio-frequency interference.” According to the Research Report on Space Traffic Management issued by the IAA in 2006, space traffic management, with the aim to maintain space order and protect space safety, includes at least three major areas: data collection and space situational awareness, space notification system, and specific traffic management rules.

Space traffic management is vital to the maintenance of space security and orderly development of space activities. Space safety, stability and sustainability are the cornerstones of all types of space activities. Creating a safe, stable and sustainable space environment is the common interest and responsible of all space-faring nations.

Avoiding collisions in outer space is a means to ensure space safety. Accordingly, space traffic management shall strive to avoid potential space collisions and ensure the safe passage of outer space and return to Earth. With a large number of moving space debris in outer space, there is a need to constantly update real-time data to avoid potential collisions. In addition to space debris, many satellites already in orbit have the potential to collide with other objects. There are normally two steps to prevent satellite collisions: collision risk assessment, and collision avoidance maneuver. Collision risk assessment is to predict the collision probability of an in-orbit space object with other objects. Collision avoidance manoeuvres are to take active actions by menoeuevering an in-orbit space object to avoid collisions. The effectiveness of these two steps relies heavily on the information sharing of the on-orbit positions of space objects in advance through space traffic management, so that all parties can reasonably predict and maneuver.

From the 1990s to the early 2000s, relevant discussions were still limited to the theoretical and conceptual stage. Starting from the 2010s, some concrete steps were taken to put academic discussions into practice. The Draft Code of Conduct for International Space Activities put forward by the European Union in 2014 reflects the initial steps in tackling the issue of space traffic management. During the annual session of the Legal Subcommittee of the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (UNCOPUOS) in April 2015, the delegations of Germany and Luxembourg co-sponsored a new proposal to include a new agenda item on the exchange of views on the concept of space traffic management. The United States (U.S.) issued Space Policy Order No. 3 in 2018 with the aim to establish relevant responsibility and liability systems in the international governance regime for space transportation. Meanwhile, the U.S. Department of Defense issued a document entitled Space Defense Strategy in June 2020, which emphasized the importance of sustainability of U.S. space activities and its leading role in the negotiations for an international governance regime for space transportation. It is to be noted that the concept of space traffic management in the U.S. focuses on how to ensure national safety through the clarification of relevant criteria and requirements for traffic management; and the U.S.’ leading position in the space arena through the promotion of military-civilian integration.

The United Nations (UN) has played an important role in the enactment of space law rules and will continue its efforts in the field of space traffic management. The trend is clear that the UN aims to set up a pragmatic mechanism in coordinating and promoting cooperation among all States to facilitate the consensus-building process in order to reduce space collisions, enhance space sustainability and improve information sharing through space situational awareness mechanisms. In the meantime, the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), as a specialized Agency of the UN, has also started concrete research work at the international level, it would be useful to examine possible measures to be taken in the interim before any legal framework is instituted. It is expected that the work on space traffic management will have a major impact on future development of space law.

The role of soft law rules for space traffic management

Space activities are closely related to national safety and security. However, with more and more states joining the space club, the consensus on a binding legal document becomes increasingly difficult. The whole process has been more complicated with the involvement of private entities. As such, there is a need to look to soft law rules for immediate solutions. In this regard, relevant soft law documents relating to space debris mitigation and space sustainability would help to clarify certain issues involved in space traffic management. Such documents include the UNCOPUOS Space Debris Mitigation Guidelines, the UNCOPUOS Guidelines for the Long-term Sustainability of Outer Space Activities, and the UN Group of Governments Expert (GGE) Report on Transparency and Confidence-building Measures (TCBMs) in Outer Space Activities.

An international regulatory body

It is essential to have an international regulatory body to deal with space traffic management for civil and commercial purposes. This entity would play a role in the coordination and enforcement of relevant traffic rules.  Due account should also be given to issues such as space debris mitigation, space data sharing, and establishment of relevant safety standards. The principle of international cooperation has been emphasized on various occasions for space activities. No single country can effectively manage space traffic alone. Cooperation in space traffic management is of utmost importance to the success of future space tourism and transportation. A neutral cooperative platform through an international regulatory body shall be the ideal way out. The ICAO, in view of its rich experience in civil traffic management, shall be the ideal entity to take up this role. This body shall also work closely with the national entities in the field and coordinate their work at the international level.

Space situational awareness (SSA)

Space situational awareness, involving data exchange and information sharing, is essential for space traffic management. It refers to the recognition of the necessary and predictable space environment and the operational environment on which space activities depend, including the positions and movements of space objects in orbit. Accurate information on the location and surrounding environment of satellites and/or space debris is vital to the safety and security of space activities. SSA could be understood in a broad sense through three mission stages: 1) collecting various data of space objects; 2) analyzing the data to predict the probability of close encounter between two space objects and the risk of re-entry; 3) communicating with stakeholders about potential risks so that necessary actions can be taken.

At the moment, only a handful of States have space situational awareness systems and capabilities; no country can simply rely on its own efforts to achieve accurate cognition of all space objects in the world. Consequently, there is a need for the international community to share SSA data. Since the Outer Space Treaty or other existing binding space treaties do not provide for the duty to disclose and share SSA data, it is necessary to establish an international coordination mechanism for an integrated space situational awareness system, which can provide a reliable and accurate situational judgment source and foundation for space traffic management.

With the ongoing space commercialization and privatization, more and more private entities become the providers of relevant space data. The participation of private entities is undoubtedly conducive to the sharing of space data; however, no clear rules are in place regarding the rights and obligations these private entities enjoy in the process of data sharing. Accordingly, further rules should be clarified regarding the duty of data sharing in space traffic management, the scope, and standards for data sharing.

Very closely related to the SSA, registration of space objects is important in improving transparency in outer space and space activities. An important prerequisite for the successful development of shared space situational awareness is to ensure that the shared data is effectively regulated. The information provided in the registration can serve as the firsthand source for the SSA purpose. The Registration Convention and the UNGA resolution on improving the registration practice offer necessary rules on the registration of space objects. However, when space transportation becomes more frequent, there is a need to explore a separate/or different regime regarding the registration of spacecraft for the purpose of regular commercial transportations.

To conclude, peaceful exploration and use of outer space has always been the unremitting pursuit of mankind. With more and more States attaching importance to and actively participating in the development of space industry, space technologies are having a significant and far-reaching impact on the way of life of human society. At a new historical starting point, space traffic management has entered the public’s field of vision. While realizing that it may bring fundamental contributions to aerospace development, it is necessary to look into possible legal framework to regulate space traffic and improve the global sharing of space situational awareness, so that space technologies can serve and enhance human well-being in a wider, deeper and higher level. This will in turn bring peace and harmony to humankind and betterment of their life.


* Henry Cheng Professor in International Law and Head of the Department of Law, The University of Hong Kong.

Unraveling the Space Debris Enigma

Geetanjali R Kamat*

Key Words: COPUOS – Non-binding mitigation guidelines – Space debris – Standardization – Sustainability

The twenty-first century is witnessing the emergence of a new era with countries striving to leave their mark in outer space. With more nations willing to compete in the global space race, the future of space exploration looks promising. At the same time, countries are increasingly becoming concerned of the consequences of such activities on the space and the earth’s environment. One such issue is that of “space debris” – a topic which has been subject to years of scientific research and several discussions. In May 2021, the debris from China’s Long March-5B rocket, used to launch its new space station (Tiangong), crashed into the Indian Ocean near Maldives.[ii] Although instances of space debris resulting in damage to spacecrafts, or territories on the earth’s surface are not unprecedented, this incident reiterated the absence of binding international law regarding space debris.

Legal Regime

Presently, international space law requires States to (a) bear international responsibility for conducting national activities in outer space[iii]; and (b) return space objects, if found within their territory, to the state of registry.[iv] In terms of liability, a “launching state” is absolutely liable for damage caused to another State, by its space object, on the earth’s surface or to aircraft in flight.[v] However, in case of damage caused by a space object of one launching state to a space object, or to a person or property on board a space object of another launching state in outer space or in airspace, a fault-based standard of liability will be imposed on the former.[vi]

Apart from the Outer Space Treaty and the Liability Convention, we have bodies such as the Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordination Committee (hereinafter ‘IADC’) and the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (hereinafter ‘COPUOS’), along with national and international space agencies, working on this problem. In 2002, IADC issued the Space Debris Mitigation Guidelines (hereinafter ‘IADC Guidelines’), focusing on aspects such as minimizing the potential for on-orbit break-ups and post-mission disposal.[vii] In 2004, the European Space Agency and the national space agencies of France, Germany, the UK, and Italy adopted the European Code of Conduct for Space Debris Mitigation (hereinafter ‘the European Code of Conduct’), which is in alignment with the IADC Guidelines. Apart from providing for management measures, such as the appointment of the ‘Space Debris Manager’, the European Code of Conduct consists of design and operational measures for space debris mitigation.[viii] Similarly, using the IADC Guidelines as a starting point, COPUOS endorsed certain guidelines (hereinafter ‘the COPUOS Guidelines’) in 2007. Given the non-binding nature of the COPUOS Guidelines, member States were expected to implement “national mechanisms” with an objective to enforce space debris mitigation procedures.

Challenges

International responsibility

The Outer Space Treaty is guided by principles of co-operation and mutual assistance whereby all outer space activities are to be carried out with “due regard” to the corresponding interests of other member States.[ix] Therefore, the freedom of scientific investigation must be balanced with the larger interests of the international space community. Further, a member State is entitled to request consultation concerning the outer space activity with another member State if it has “reason to believe” that such activity would cause potentially harmful interference with the peaceful exploration of outer space.[x] While a member State is, in theory, permitted to exercise such a diplomatic tool, the extent of its enforceability and the effectiveness of such dialogue are uncertain.

Space sustainability

Another important facet of the international approach to long-term sustainability of space activities includes the comprehensive set of standards provided by the International Organization for Standardization (hereinafter  ‘the ISO Standards’). The ISO Standards specify prudent measures for designing and operating spacecrafts in a safe manner with an objective to prevent creation of space debris. In the past, the ISO Standards have benefitted Ukraine, which used these standards to conduct space debris mitigation evaluations of its launch vehicle systems.[xi] Therefore, it is crucial that States strictly comply with the ISO Standards or alternatively, formulate their own measures to implement a procedural framework for space debris mitigation which regulates different stages of space systems. However, if States adopt vastly different standards, this may potentially lead to inconsistent compliance and varying interpretation of “sufficient” space debris mitigation measures.

Way Forward

Incentivizing space debris mitigation

In a welcome move, the ‘Global Future Council on Space Technologies’ has developed the concept of Space Sustainability Rating (hereinafter ‘Sustainability Rating’), which is expected to come into effect early next year. The Sustainability Rating seeks to encourage responsible behaviour in outer space by increasing the transparency of the debris mitigation efforts.[xii] There is a possibility that in the near future, rankings in terms of Sustainability Ratings may even provide a hierarchy of “ethical spacefaring nations” and incentivize States to pay greater attention to space debris mitigation.

Liability Convention

It is a generally agreed principle that damage to the outer space environment does not directly fall within the scope of the Liability Convention.[xiii] Accordingly, accidents which occur due to a space object, either in outer space, to an aircraft in flight, or on the earth’s surface, warrant a separate framework for assessing “damage” and providing “standards of liability”. It is prudent that a stricter framework for liability pertaining to the outer space environment, which also provides for reasonable exceptions, should be drafted in order to enforce an otherwise soft law. Another question worth considering is the stage at which States ought to be held accountable for undertaking space exploration activities in a reckless manner. Instead of risking damage to lives and property owing to an unpredictable trajectory, there should be a uniform mechanism for settling apprehensions in this regard.

Steps taken by India

The Indian Space Research Organization has been an active member of IADC since 1996. As of June 2021, India is in the process of formally adopting a national mechanism on space debris mitigation and strengthening the domestic requirements for Indian entities.[xiv] In the same month, the Department of Space circulated the Draft National Space Transportation Policy, 2020, (hereinafter ‘the NSTP’) for public comments.[xv] The pro forma for obtaining authorizations for launches and sub-orbital launches in the NSTP requires the relevant launching entity to provide a “space debris mitigation plan”. Thus, the fact that applicants are required to provide their “space debris mitigation plans” signifies the proactive approach by the Indian government towards minimization of space debris.

Periodic updates

The existing standards and guidelines in respect of space debris mitigation are revised on a periodic basis to accommodate new developments in this regard. For instance, the IADC Guidelines were revised in June 2021 to provide clarifications on parameters such as operational phases and re-entry risks. Similarly, the ISO Standards were revised in July 2019. Hence, it is crucial that countries also make corresponding revisions to their national policies and frameworks concerning mitigation of space debris and implement effective measures.

Concluding Remarks

Currently, there is no internationally binding treaty on space debris. Additionally, existing policies such as the IADC Guidelines, the COPUOS Guidelines and the European Code of Conduct are non-binding and voluntary in nature. The need of the hour is to evaluate the extent to which existing guidelines, standardization measures and best practices, for mitigating space debris, have proven to be helpful. If a majority of States have enforced useful robust national mechanisms, these guidelines may well have succeeded. However, in case these have been inadequate or unclear, a binding international legal instrument which would tackle such a problem in a uniform and coherent manner will need to be implemented. At the same time, one cannot lose sight of the fact that adopting mitigation measures, including compliance with the ISO Standards, may involve complex technology and high costs. Accordingly, the binding legal framework, if it were to be created, must uphold the overarching fundamentals of space law – principles of equality and non-discrimination.


[i] Geetanjali R Kamat is an Ex-Associate at Touchstone Partners and Founder-Editor at IRCCL

 

[ii] See https://www.firstpost.com/world/debris-from-chinas-long-march-rocket-disintegrates-over-indian-ocean-lands-near-maldives-9605491.html. Last visited, 23 July 2021.

[iii] Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies (Outer Space Treaty) 1967, Art. VI.

[iv] Outer Space Treaty, Art. VIII.

[v] Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects (Liability Convention) 1972, Art. II.

[vi] Liability Convention, Art. III.

[vii] See https://www.unoosa.org/documents/pdf/spacelaw/sd/IADC.pdf. Last visited, 24 July 2021.

[viii]  See https://www.unoosa.org/documents/pdf/spacelaw/sd/2004-B5-10.pdf. Last visited, 30 July 2021.

[ix] Outer Space Treaty, Art. IX.

[x]Ibid.

[xi] See http://undocs.org/en/A/AC.105/C.1/118. Last visited, 24 July 2021.

[xii] See https://www.weforum.org/projects/space-sustainability-rating. Last visited, 25 July 2021.

[xiii] See https://www.princeton.edu/~ota/disk2/1990/9033/9033.PDF. Last visited, 24 July 2021.

[xiv] See https://www.unoosa.org/documents/pdf/spacelaw/sd/India.pdf. Last visited, 24 July 2021.

[xv] See https://www.isro.gov.in/sites/default/files/draft_national_space_transportation_policy.pdf. Last visited, 23 July 2021.