Chandrayaan – 3: An Opportunity to Set Right the Mistake of Artemis Accords

Prof. (Dr.) Sandeepa Bhat B.*

Keywords:   Artemis Program – Chandrayaan – 2 – Common rights’ regime – Outer Space Treaty – Soft landing

Chandrayaan – 3: An Accomplishment to Cherish

Among all odds and speculations, India successfully made a soft landing on the moon on 23 August 2023. The previous experience of Chandrayaan – 2’s failure to have soft landing of the lander and the rover was haunting the entire nation till the last minute. Though Chandrayaan – 2 was successful in placing the lunar orbiter as intended, lunar landing remained an uncherished dream of the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO). Chandrayaan – 3 could successfully land the Vikram lander and the Pragyan rover near the South Pole region of the moon. Though India is the fourth State after Russia, the United States and China to land on the moon, it is the first to land near the South Pole of the moon. The Pragyan rover has already made several discoveries that are of immense scientific significance. Hence, Chandrayaan – 3 has garnered great attention of the international community, including that of space-faring nations.

The soft landing of a space object on the moon dates back to 1966 when the erstwhile Soviet Union’s Luna 9 made the first soft landing on the moon. This triggered a race between the Soviet Union and the United States, which ultimately resulted in “one giant leap for mankind”, the first human landing on the moon in 1969. Despite the lunar landings have started more than five decades ago, technological developments in both the United States and Russia have not reached a level, which is beyond uncertainties. This is reflected in Russia’s recent failure to land Luna 25 on the moon, which was supposed to land in the South Pole region of the moon on 21 August 2023. The fact that India could able to land successfully during the same week makes the achievement special. It is also a reflection of the fact that India is now a force to be reckoned with in terms of activities on the moon and other celestial bodies.

Celestial Mining and Artemis Accords

The twenty-first century developments in the space sector are moving too much in the direction of commercialisation. We have gone beyond the use of earth orbits for commercial activities, like direct television broadcasting, remote sensing, telecommunication, navigation, etc., to grab and exploit the celestial resources. Some States have also structured their domestic laws to provide legal sanctity for celestial resource exploitation. The United States, Luxemburg, United Arab Emirates and Japan have already enacted such laws to permit celestial mining. Saudi Arabia has also shown its strong zeal in this direction by depositing a notification with the United Nations for its withdrawal from the Moon Agreement 1979. In November 2022, Japan went on to authorise iSpace, a private company, to conduct commercial activities on the moon and sell resources for profit.

While these developments were taking place in the domestic legal positions of some States, the United States has come up with a bigger plan in the form of Artemis Accords in 2020. The Artemis Accords carry 13 provisions for cooperation in the civil exploration and use of celestial bodies. They are characterised as non-binding understanding between the participating States to ensure the smooth conduct of activities on celestial bodies. Interestingly, the Artemis Accords has been signed by various authorities ranging from representatives of respective State’s space agency to some ministers or even ambassadors for different States.

The Artemis Accords are a part of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s (NASA)Artemis Program, which involves a stage-by-stage journey toward celestial bodies. In this connection, NASA has successfully launched Artemis 1, which involved the exploration around the moon and return to earth to ensure that the technology is adequate enough for safe journey to lunar orbit. The next two Artemis missions are intended to perform human lunar flyby and human landing respectively. The Artemis Program also dreams of constructing a lunar orbital station- lunar ‘Gateway’, and a self sustaining base on the moon- ‘Artemis Base Camp’.

An Indian Mistake

After the Artemis Accords were signed by the initial signatories, the efforts to increase the number of participating States got intensified. Two other major space-faring nations, Russia and China, have rejected to concede the Artemis Accords. Instead, they have teamed up to have a parallel joint project in the form of the International Lunar Research Station. India kept itself away from the Artemis Accords for nearly three years. However, after a wait and watch game, it became the twenty seventh signatory to the Artemis Accords on 21 June 2023 when the Indian ambassador to the United States, Mr. Taranjit Singh Sindhu, signed it on behalf of India.

Keeping aside any political consideration, this is a move that India should have never played from the legal standpoint. The Artemis Accords and its umbrella cover of the Artemis Program are in direct violation of international space treaties’ obligations. Though there are multiple contradictions with the provisions of the Outer Space Treaty, the author would like to highlight the most significant of all for the purpose of this blog piece, which is indisputably the violation of the principle of non-appropriation.

The Outer Space Treaty is the reflection of the common rights’ regime, which originates from the universal understanding that space resources are bounties of nature and everyone should have rights in them. The need for carrying out the exploration and the use of outer space and celestial bodies for the benefit and in the interests of all countries, along with equality of access to all areas and freedom of scientific investigation to all, stand as the foundational principles in this regard under Article I of the Outer Space Treaty. Article II of the Outer Space Treaty carries forward the elements of common rights’ regime by prohibiting national appropriation of outer space and celestial bodies “by claim of sovereignty, by means of use or occupation, or by any other means.” Despite the common rights’ regime is taken to the next level under the Moon Agreement 1979 with the incorporation of the common heritage of mankind, its practical implication has taken a backseat due to the limited ratification of the Moon Agreement. 

These principles of common rights’ regime have taken shape in space law due to the relentless efforts of the third world States.[1] With the failure of the Moon Agreement, Article II read with Article I of the Outer Space Treaty remained as the sanctum sanctorum of the common rights’ regime in space law. Sections 9 and 10 of the Artemis Accords pose serious challenges to these principles of common rights. Section 9 stipulates the preservation of outer space heritage without outlining how encompassing such a right of preservation will be. This is dangerous as the measures taken in preserving space heritages will be subjective and might result in creating monopolistic rights in contravention of common rights’ regime.

Section 10 is of greater concern as it advocates for laying hands on celestial resources for commercial exploitation. It is based on the wrong presumption that the Outer Space Treaty does not deal with celestial resources. The legal uncertainty of Section 10 is evident in the provision itself as the drafters stipulate this as not a contravention of Article II of the Outer Space Treaty. It is unbecoming of any international instrument, legal or otherwise, to include such an unwarranted justification for a provision unless there exists an inconsistency. Commercial utilisation of celestial resources by select few States under the garb of the Artemis Accords undoubtedly amounts to national appropriation by “use” or by “other means” contrary to the essence of Article II of the Outer Space Treaty. This is also at odds with India’s historic stand against individual appropriation evident in its United Nations deliberations during 1970s. It is significant to note here that along with Egypt and Nigeria, India had opposed the United States’ position on resource exploitation in 1974.[2] Now, signing Artemis Accords indicate a U-turn in the Indian assertion of third world approach, and more dangerously, acceding the US imperialism.

What Next?

This is not the time for repenting on whatever has happened. This is the time for carrying forward by accepting the current position of India being a part of the Artemis Accords. We have to assess and revaluate the Artemis Accords as well as its bigger counterpart of Artemis Program to bring them in tune with the common rights’ regime. The most significant step in this direction is to shift the spirit of bilateralism or plurilateralism of the Artemis Accords to multilateralism by involving all States in negotiating an acceptable regime for celestial resources. For this, bridging the gap between Artemis Accords and Lunar Station project as well as taking the confidence of developing and less developed States are crucial. We should take lessons from the unilateralism of the United States in the deep seabed exploitation to collectively condemn the extension of it to celestial resources. Our achievement of Chandrayaan – 3 should be viewed as a tool for having an independent say to uphold the integrity ofthe common rights’ regime in international space law.


* Professor of Law, Director – Centre for Aviation and Space Laws, The WB National University of Juridical Sciences, Salt Lake City, Kolkata.

References:

[1] Robert J. Griffiths, ‘From the Ocean Floor to Outer Space: The Third World and Global Commons Negotiations’, Journal of Third World Studies , Vol. 9, No. 2, 1992, pp. 375 – 389.

[2] Stephen D. Mau, ‘Equity, the Third World and the Moon Treaty’, Suffolk Transnational Law Journal, Vol. 8, No. 2, 1984, pp. 221 – 258 at p. 250.

Humans in Space Policy for India 2021

Sandeepa Bhat B.*

Key Words:          Common rights – DoS/ISRO – Gaganyaan – Intellectual property – Space Act of India

India has evolved as a major space power over the years. The twenty-first century India has been successful in reaching the moon and the mars, which has been accomplished earlier by only three other States in the world[1]. The plan for the Indian human mission to the outer space (Gaganyaan) has been under consideration for more than a decade. Accomplishing it would also place India on the list of the select few States to achieve this feet of human presence in outer space. With an objective to have sustained human presence in outer space for enabling socio-economic growth, the Department of Space has come-up with the Draft Humans in Space Policy for India 2021 (hereinafter ‘the Draft Policy’), which was opened for public comments in February 2021.[2]

The Policy and its Execution

         The Preamble of the Draft Policy recognises the changing dimensions of space activities with the entry of private players into the field. The Indian Government is making efforts to unlock the space sector for incentivising private investments with an objective to boost its ailing economy, especially after the unprecedented economic impact of COVID-19. Through the Draft Policy, as stated in the Preamble, efforts are made towards the adoption of regulatory framework and partnership-building with the public-private associations. This policy framework for human spaceflight is intended to foster collaborations and address proliferation concerns. A reference can also be found in the Preamble on the compliance of laws, policies and treaties in the process of space capacity-building and furthering India’s role in the space sector.

         Though the scope of the Draft Policy vaguely refers to activities under the Indian human space programme and future activities in conjunction with them without any definition, it seems to apply the proposed policy to both public and private sector activities. The substance of the Draft Policy mentions the basic policy principle as “The Humans in Space Policy aims for sustained human presence in space as an instrument for development, innovation and foster collaborations in alignment with national interests.” Though catering to the national interests is significant for the States, the need for fostering the international interest is equally significant in the field of outer space activities. The entire edifice of space law is rooted in the common rights’ principles developed under the five international space treaties of the twentieth century entered under the patronage of the United Nations.[3] Thus, we have the principles like; province of all mankind, absence of national or individual appropriation, considering the interests and benefits of all countries, international cooperation etc. advocated under the space treaties. India, being a strong advocate of common rights’ regime in outer space, should recognise the interest of the international community in its every law and policy objective.

         Execution of activities of human space programme is to be done by the Department of Space or by the Indian Space Research Organization (hereinafter ‘the DoS/ISRO’). The Draft Policy confers wide power to the DoS/ISRO to develop various guidelines including ‘approval-mechanism’ for “activities under the Indian human space programme in confirmation with extant Space Act of India and policy.”[4] There are two concerns that arise out of this. First, this provision is based on the assumption of an enabling law for approval-mechanism, which has not been adopted till date in India. In the absence of an enabling legislation, delegating the power of authorisation to the DoS/ISRO without any legislative framework is questionable. Second, the clubbing of power of authorization and execution with the same agency is also a matter of concern as it amounts to a situation of the DoS/ISRO self-judging its activities. An independent agency to scrutinise the preparedness, safety, security and various compliances for authorization is essential since authorization for any space activity is associated with the burden of State responsibility[5] and international liability[6] under the space treaties. In the event of any disaster due to the lack of preparedness or inadequate safety measures either by the DoS/ISRO or by its private partner, the State exchequer would be hit hard for compensating the victims. This can simply be averted with a second level check of independent scrutiny.

Guidelines

         The next part of the Draft Policy provides for eight guidelines to be followed by the Department of Space in connection with the Gaganyaan. These guidelines include the demonstration of capability for human space flight, developing a long-term roadmap for sustained human missions to outer space, identifying and developing necessary technologies, enabling greater participation of various stakeholders, developing collaborative framework for scientific research, fostering international cooperation to develop collaborative programmes, developing human resources and encouraging entrepreneurship, and promoting outreach activities to encourage public involvement in human space programmes. Though these guidelines are significant in achieving sustained human missions to outer space, much depends on the practical implementation of these guidelines. Unfortunately, the Draft Policy doesn’t provide for the specific nuances in terms of the implementation of the guidelines.

Procedures?

         The last part of the Draft Policy mentions about the procedures, which seems to be a misnomer. Though it mentions about following certain procedures by the DoS/ISRO in implementing some of the guidelines, none of the four clauses in this part is on the procedure to be followed. The first clause mentions about the establishment of a national level body by the DoS/ISRO for supervising and coordinating collaborative ventures. Clauses 2 and 3 under this part entrust the DoS/ISRO to develop certification process for crew safety and to set criteria for crew selection. The last clause mentions about the application of the Space Act of India regarding the protection of intellectual property rights and settlement of disputes. Hence, none of the clauses provide for any procedure for implementing the guidelines. The proposed national level body under this part is primarily for coordination between various stakeholders and also for overseeing the activities under human space programmes. As it is intended to oversee all human space missions including the ISRO missions, the DoS/ISRO’s control over it cannot be justified from a legal perspective. Moreover, the Draft Policy fails to delineate the powers, responsibilities and role of different bodies like the ISRO, Antrix Corporation, NewSpace India Limited, and the proposed new national level body in connection with the human space missions.

         On the intellectual property and dispute settlement clause, it is also pertinent to note here that the current status of the intellectual property rights’ protection in outer space under the Indian laws is quite unclear. Only reference to space-based intellectual property rights can be seen in the Draft Space Activities Bill 2017 (hereinafter ‘the Draft Bill’)[7]. Section 25(1) of the Draft Bill stipulates the protection of intellectual property rights generated or created during the course of any activity under any law for the time being in force. However, Section 25(2) confers the property rights to the Central Government on the space-based intellectual property created on board any space object. Unless there is change in this position of State monopoly over space-based intellectual property rights, the collaborative human space activities advocated under the Draft Policy would remain as a distant dream in India. It is obvious that the private players would have no incentive to make huge investments in human space missions when they are aware of the fact that their stake in the intellectual property rights would be usurped by the State. The reference by the Draft Policy to the Space Act of India for the settlement of disputes is also misleading as there is no clause on the settlement of disputes under the Draft Bill.

Concluding Remarks

         In the ultimate analysis, developing policy guidelines for the sustained human space activities in India is a welcome step. However, the current Draft Policy suffers from several limitations as highlighted above. It lacks long-term vision and requisite details for having a comprehensive policy. More significantly, the much needed legal understanding, which is indispensable in dealing with any space activity, is completely missing under the Draft Policy. Hence, it is advisable to revisit the Draft Policy to have a comprehensive, legally appropriate and transparent policy framework to facilitate collaborative ventures as has been intended by the drafters.


References:

* Professor of Law & Director – Centre for Aviation and Space Laws, The WB National University of Juridical Sciences, Sec. III, Salt Lake City, Kolkata. INDIA.

[1] The Soviet Union/Russia, the United States of America and China are the only three other States.

[2] See https://www.isro.gov.in/sites/default/files/draft_humans_in_space_policy-02.pdf Last visited, 2 July 2021.

[3] Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies (Outer Space Treaty) 1967, Agreement on the Rescue of Astronauts, the Return of Astronauts and the Return of Objects Launched into Outer Space (Rescue Agreement) 1968, Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects (Liability Convention) 1972, Convention on Registration of Objects Launched into Outer Space (Registration Convention) 1975 and Agreement Governing the Activities of States on the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies (Moon Agreement) 1979.

[4] See supra note 2, Clause 4.

[5] Outer Space Treaty, Art. VI.

[6] Ibid, Art. VII and Liability Convention.

[7] See https://www.isro.gov.in/update/21-nov-2017/seeking-comments-draft-space-activities-bill-2017-stake-holders-public-regarding Last visited, 2 July 2021.